Meet Toronto's Citybuilders
Become a CityPatron
  Learn about the program
Get the CP Bulletin
 

Just to be clear: This is an idea. It's a beta. But with your encouragement we think it could work.

Here's our argument: Just as engines need spark plugs, cities need people who can turn good ideas into action.The private sector knows this. The marketplace celebrates innovators and entrepreneurs who dream up the next big idea for a product or a company. But in the civic arena, it's a different story.

There's no research and development and very little real risk-taking. Instead, resources are dependent on short-term ‘deliverables’. Projects that tilt political are seen as troublesome or worse. Young leaders aren't given meaningful opportunities to prove their stuff. Too often rigid board structures and bureaucracies call the shots. Staying power and safety are rewarded rather than insight and ingenuity.

Sure, in Toronto we talk a good game about innovation and leadership. But we seem to forget that real innovation is messy and that failure is often as important as success.

We talk about creativity, but we don't invest in it — much less in the real dreamers, tireless inventors and public convenors — the people who are out there on the edge, and reporting back to the rest of us where we could go and how we could get there.

Just as a tree begins with a tiny seed and a lot of water, our greatest city projects begin with seed planters that require resources to transform their ideas into reality. Often, once the project gets off the ground, conventional funding becomes attainable. Civic entrepreneurs income stream to support their work, especially when they are at the earliest stages of developing innovative projects that have the potential to help transform our city. 'Crowdsourcing' an income for proven CityBuilders fundamentally is what CityPatron is all about.

Patronage for the people...by the people
Okay. We know that patronage is an old-fashioned word and carries a lot of other baggage besides. But when we think about 'patronage' we're thinking about it as a business model — one with a remarkable and rich history. Before there were arts councils or science foundations, there were patrons enobling themselves or their cities by funding artists and inventors to create works of unique beauty or public utility.

We want to democratize the patronage process.
After all, why should it only be rich people who get to work with artists and inventors and share in the excitement and beauty of their creative process?

This is a simple idea. To start, the CityPatron program will select four to six new CityBuilders each year. CityBuilders will be extraordinary Torontonians who have a track record of creating public value for the city. This could include creating works of art, activism or civic entrepreneurship — but broadly we mean people who work to make the city a better, more interesting place for its residents.

CityBuilders will post a profile and, importantly, a program of work. This program will outline what they propose to do for the funding or patronage they receive. CityPatrons will then support the CityBuilder of their choice, pledging $5, $10, $20, $50 or $100 a month for one year. In return, the CityBuilder will provide his or her patrons with a monthly newsletter that chronicles their work, and invitations to special events held periodically throughout the year.

If this works as we intend, CityPatrons will get to support a program of work they believe in, and share in the CityBuilder's creative process and success. CityBuilders get access to the resources they need to get on with their work, creating a better, livelier city.

 



We want to hear from you

Read the Toronto Star article

 







  Following a shotgun launch in January, we were grateful to hear from dozens of Torontonians and city organizations who want to support this program. Right now we're busy drawing up some guidelines, sort through some backstage details, and recruit our first slate of amazing CityBuilders. Stay tuned for details. Meanwhile, we have a brave beta candidate in Dave Meslin who has agreed to put himself forward as the program's first CityBuilder, and help us by providing feedback as we test the concept — as we support his work by providing a growing revenue stream. Those who know Mez, know that he's one of Toronto's most respected civic entrepreneurs. We want to make it easier for Mez and other CityBuilders to do what they do best: create audacious and important programs and organizations that keep the city humming.

You can read the articles that helped to inspire the CityBuilder concept here and here.

...And if you think this really is a good idea and you'd like to help support Mez's work right now, you can become a CityPatron Pioneer.

 
  CityPatron helps to support people in the city who get good things done. It's not an expensive proposition. You can choose how much you donate via our monthly direct debit system and cancel your patronage whenever you choose. Because, hey, circumstances and priorities change. We get that — it's part of the power of this program. By 'crowdsourcing' or sharing the load and dividing the CityBuilder's salary into small chunks, we can all do our bit to help good people do good work for the city.

 
 

As we continue to refine the concept, we'll post our thinking here. For now we thought we'd start with some obvious questions.

Where did this idea come from?

It's been brewing for the past six months and like so many things, necessity really is the mother of invention. Over the course of the summer Dave Meslin and Peter MacLeod started talking seriously about whether you could design a different funding model that could assist undercapitalized artists and entrepreneurs doing important work throughout the city. Many cups of coffee later, the CityPatron concept started to form... Then Mez put up a facebook post floating the idea. Catherine Porter at the Toronto Star got in touch and wanted to write a column on the concept. We scrambled to launch this site in time to have the url printed in the paper. And bang... we're live.

How much money will each CityBuilder receive?

Right now, the purpose of the program is to fund salaries. We might change this to include project work, but we know from our own experience that raising an entire salary has a dramatically greater impact on a CityBuilder's productivity then only funding a portion of their expenses.

Currently, the average salary in Toronto is approximately $56,000 and across Canada the average salary is $44,000. We think CityBuilders should receive somewhere between $30,000 and $40,000 to do their work. To qualify, CityBuilders must disclose their anticipated sources of income, and their total personal income, including the CityPatron salary, should not exceed the national average. Fundraising is suspended when that modest limit is reached. This isn't about getting rich or more then you need.

Still, that sounds like a lot of money to raise...

It does, until you start to do the math. For instance, 150 CityPatrons donating just $20 a month would provide a CityBuilder with $36,000 a year. 100 CityPatrons giving $30 a month could do the same thing.

Will I get a tax receipt?

Ultimately, we hope so. We're looking into it now. If you have any expertise with charitable law and the use of charitable numbers, drop us a line.

What happens next?

In part that's up to you. We want your help refining this idea and if we hear enough good things, then we'll commit to turn this concept into a model that can fund four to six CityBuilders each year.

So ask yourself: Would you fund a CityBuilder? If so, why? And if no, why not? Tell us. We'll wait a week or two and make our decision. If you want to help, volunteer... we need writers, coders and more publicity to make this work.

I want to help. What can I do right now?

Share this site with a friend and help us build some buzzzzzz...

Bookmark and Share
What is MASS LBP?

MASS LBP is a Toronto-based company that is working to reinvent public consultation. We've agreed to host this site and help incubate the concept. You can learn more about what we do here.